بایگانی برچسب برای: حسین حیدرپور

پرسش و پاسخ با گلن نیلی-49

Can a 5th wave be a Diametric formation?

ANSWER:

Sent in by Rajkumaar Perumal of Chennai, India, the answer to this week’s question can be found by focusing on the internal design of an impulse pattern. A standard (trending) impulsion’s internal structure is :5 :3 :5 :3 :5, whereas a terminal impulse is a :3 :3 :3 :3 :3 affair. 

Since a Diametric formation always compacts to a :3 (ie, a correction), the ONLY time a Diametric can occur as the 5th wave of an impulsion is when that impulsion is Terminal in design.

پرسش و پاسخ با گلن نیلی-48

Why do you sometimes trade contrary to your forecasts?

ANSWER:

This question has been posed by so many people over so many years that I thought it was time for an “official” answer. 

To the neophyte, the world of trading is all about forecasting. They think, “If I could just forecast what�s going to happen, then I could make money.” In fact, the entire financial industry is founded on the assumption “you can�t make money unless you can accurately predict the future.” This is what I call the “Forecasting Paradigm” and is the foundation of nearly every product and service offered to the investing public.

Unfortunately, the “Forecasting Paradigm” is false. For example, do you have to predict the future to get there? Do you have to predict the direction of a river to make it to the ocean? Do you have to predict the direction of the wind to man a sailboat? Does a doctor “predict” you have a tumor or does he observe it on an x-ray and inform you of its existence? 

Successful trading is about risk management, market observation and stop movement, NOT about forecasting. It depends on your ability to remove opinion and emotion from the process and learn to “go with the flow,” doing what the market tells you to do instead of you telling it what it should do. 

The recommendations in my NEoWave Trading service are the result of a paradigm shift in my understanding of how markets operate and how to trade them. I�m sure long-term subscribers have noticed this shift over the years. The result of more than 20 years of studying markets, this is what my cutting-edge, NEELY RIVER trading technology is all about. NEELY RIVER Technology addresses and eliminates all the problems associated with trading failure, allowing you to “naturally evolve” into a successful investor. Furthermore, by eliminating the “Forecasting Paradigm” from the trading process, it allows you to dramatically reduce the time spent looking at markets and completely eliminates the time spent trying to predict them. 

Realizing long ago the difference between trading and forecasting, I separated my NEoWave services into two, distinct products – the educationally oriented Chart service and the profit oriented Trading service. Some prefer making their own trading decisions (based on my NEoWave forecasts in the chart service), while others prefer taking advantage of my trading expertise to guide them through the process successfully.

پرسش و پاسخ با گلن نیلی-47

How important is the “Overlap” rule and do you apply it strictly or loosely.

ANSWER:

Sent in by an anonymous client, this concept was discovered by R.N. Elliott. For a complete discussion of this rule, please see page 5-8 of Mastering Elliott Wave. The “overlap” rule is essential to accurate wave analysis and forecasting, without which the theory would be rendered virtually useless. Nearly any scenario desired can be concocted if one fails to apply the “overlap” rule. Therefore, the answer is the rule must be strictly applied.

 

The “overlap” rule, I suspect, has come into question the last decade or two due to the general appeal and popularity of non-agricultural, futures markets. Futures markets possess characteristics not well-suited for wave analysis. Primarily, all futures markets have expiration dates that create a disconnect and price distortion from one contract month to the next. Secondly, there is a premium added to Futures prices that slowly decays over time until expiration. Both of these realities create havoc for accurate wave analysis. This is the reason I stress the importance of non-expiring, non-spot-based, true cash data for all wave analysis.

 

 

پرسش و پاسخ با گلن نیلی-46

What is the best and safest approach to trade an impulse wave? Many books say “exit at end of wave 1, reenter at low of 2, exit at end of 3, reenter during wave 4, exit at end of 5.”

ANSWER:

This very important question was sent in by Afshin Pishdad of Ontario, Canada. It would be great if we could all accomplish what so many trading books on wave theory espouse. Unfortunately, in the real world, what they don’t tell you (or they simply don’t know) is that wave structure is ONLY clear during wave-1, wave-5, wave-c (in Flats), wave-e (in Triangles), wave-g (in NEoWave Diametrics) and wave-i (in NEoWave Symmetricals). In other words, during the first or last wave of most patterns. Even then, unless there is sufficient detail, certainty and confidence can be low. The closer to the center of a formation a market is, the greater the level of uncertainty experienced and the greater the number of potential outcomes. 

Ironically, it is when a market is near the center of its development that most (due to confusion) seek out “advice” from experts – right at the time wave “experts” are most likely to be wrong. When near a major top or bottom (i.e, at the start or end of a trend), the public is usually convinced they know what is going to happen (wrongly so) and, as a result, have little interest in what analysts (wave or otherwise) have to say. That is exactly the time when wave analysts are most likely to be right, but at the same time ridiculed or ostracized for their opinions! What a sad state of affairs. 

So, in answer to Afshin’s question, the best and safest time to enter a market is in the reverse direction of a clear, completed 5-wave move, whether that “5-wave” move concludes wave-5 of a larger degree or wave-c of a larger degree. The next best time to enter is at the end of a 5-legged Contracting, Expanding or Neutral Triangle. Somewhat more dangerous and tricky is the end of a complex, corrective Double or Triple combination or the end of a NEoWave Diametric or Symmetrical pattern that does NOT contain an impulsive conclusion on the lower degree.
پرسش و پاسخ با گلن نیلی-45

When wave-4 is a Triangle, can any part “overlap” wave-1?

ANSWER:

This question was sent in by Ranjan Chatterjee (location unknown). Like most of the questions in this forum, the answer depends on structural conditions. If a Terminal impulse is forming (where every leg is corrective), part of wave-4 must share some of the same price range (overlap) as wave-1 and/or wave-2 whether it is a Triangle or not. In a Trending impulsion (where 1, 3 & 5 or impulsive – 2 & 4 are corrective), no part of wave-4 will share the same price range as waves-1 or 2. But, there is a caveat. For price action to adhere to the above requirement, you must use cash data for all wave charts. Due to the deterioration present in Futures data over time, structural distortion occurs, creating the potential for “overlap” that is not present on a cash chart. To avoid structural misinterpretation, I always recommend wave analysis be done on cash charts.

پرسش و پاسخ با گلن نیلی-44

In creating a wave chart, how do you decide to plot the high or low first?

ANSWER:

To produce good wave counts, wave charts are essential. A wave chart is created by plotting two price points per period (i.e., Daily, Weekly, Hourly, 5-minute, etc.) in the order they occurred during the period. Unfortunately, I have never known of a data service that produces proper wave charts, so the process must be done manually. 

To determine whether the high or low came first, create a chart composed of bars 1/40th the size of the time frame you plan to plot. For a Daily plot of the cash S&P, which is open 6.5 hours each day, 1/40th of that time is approximately 10 minutes (if your market trades 24-hours a day, 1/40th of the day is approximately 30 minutes). A chart 1/40th the size of the larger time frame will make it easy to determine whether the high or the low came first on the larger time frame. Which ever came first, place that in an Excel spreadsheet (say column 1-B) and place whatever came second in column 2-B. Place the dates in column A with the same date twice before going on to the new date. Continue this vertical, sequencial placement of data until you have enough to plot a chart. A good wave chart will contain 40 or more data points.