پرسش و پاسخ با گلن نیلی-29

Which is best, cash or futures charts?

ANSWER:

This is an issue I have grappled with for 23 years, over which time I have come to realize the answer depends on the market sector. It also depends on whether your goal is a market forecast or a profitable, low-risk trade.

The oldest futures markets (those in the agricultural sector) pose the most serious “translation” problem for the futures trader. The cash market may bare little resemblance to the futures contract, making wave analysis of cash structure nearly useless for forecasting futures prices. Additionally, if you have a position and don`t liquidate your contract soon enough, you may have to take delivery of a pile of pork bellies. The new kid on the block (Forex) is very popular because of its simplicity – no expiration date, no translation issue (the contract you trade is cash based), plus it settles in cash (nothing to deliver).

If your goal is to forecast an agricultural market, I would use the nearest futures contract on all time frames. If your goal is to profitably trade an agricultural market, I would limit the time frame followed to Weekly (or smaller) and analyze the actual contract you are trading.

If your goal is to forecast metals (Gold, Silver, Copper, etc.), natural resources (Crude Oil, Gas), stock indexes (S&P, Nasdaq, etc.) or futures based currency markets, I would use the cash market on all time frames. For real-time trading and stop placement I would use the actual futures contract on Weekly (and smaller) charts and the nearest futures on a Monthly (or larger) time frame.

If you trade Forex, the market you are trading is cash based and there is no futures contract, so all analysis and trading is done using cash on all time frames.
پرسش و پاسخ با گلن نیلی-28

You mention several ways to plot data in MEW, which is the best?

ANSWER:

The discussion in Chapter 2 (pages 9-12) of Mastering Elliott Wave on plotting data is often misunderstood. When the book was written, access to market data was not what it is today – personal computers were in their infancy. With high, low, close cash data now easy to obtain on a daily (and even an intra-day) basis, the best way to track wave structure is to plot the high and low of each session (whether hourly, daily, weekly, etc.) in the order they occurred in real-time. That is the method I use for all NEoWave CHART services.

پرسش و پاسخ با گلن نیلی-27

How is wave structure impacted by dividends and interest payments or stock splits?

ANSWER:

This question, asked by Ahmad Pesnani, is important for those trading (and applying wave theory to) equities. No matter which of the above three events occurs, it is known well in advance, giving investors plenty of time to contemplate, calculate and plan for their impact. Lacking the unexpected impact and surprise of an event such as hurricane Katrina, dividends and interest payments simply become part of the psychological fabric of a stock and should have no impact on wave structure.

Regarding stock splits, because exchanges retroactively adjust and connect historical prices for a stock to the new price level, stock splits also have no impact on wave structure. Therefore, when applying wave theory to equities, I would ignore news regarding dividends, interest payments and stock splits and simply apply all NEoWave rules as you would to any other market. 

پرسش و پاسخ با گلن نیلی-26

How do you translate your cash wave analysis into a futures market trade?

ANSWER:

This is the first question in this forum, of what I hope will be many, focusing on trading instead of wave analysis. The translation issue caused me great consternation for at least the first decade of my career, so I`m sure many of you are grappling with the process.

Due to premium decay present in most futures markets (it is most pronounced in agricultural markets and least pronounced in currency markets), accurate wave analysis requires one use cash charts. If cash structure is far from completing an important, tradable top or bottom, there is no need to keep track of futures data. When cash structure indicates an important turning point is looming (let`s assume for this example a top is forming), begin comparing recent cash highs and lows with those same futures highs and lows. Mark the cash point (in both price and time) that will confirm your count (probably the break of a low in this case). Next, find the same date on your futures chart and notice the price low of that bar. That will be the point in the futures market where you will want to enter your SELL order.

Next, if your position is activated, find the cash point (in price and time) where your trade will prove wrong and then find the same date on your futures chart. Use that future`s bar`s high for your stop.

پرسش و پاسخ با گلن نیلی-25

How do I know when a pattern starts higher than the low or lower than the high?

ANSWER:

A common mistake made by wave practitioners is that of starting wave counts from the lowest low or highest high of a market advance or decline (respectively). Probably due to the fact price lows and highs are easy to identify, most simply assume wave counts begin there. Even though the greatest financial reward or damage does occur at price extremes, Wave theory is the quantification and structuralization of mass psychology. Unfortunately, periods of pessimism and euphoria rarely conveniently peak at price tops and bottoms.

To make sure you are beginning your counts at the correct starting points, it is important you observe the behavior of price action near highs and lows. If the initial rally (off a major low) or decline (off a major high) is retraced more than 61.8%, it is nearly certain the new opposing trend will begin after that major low or high. In starting a new trend, it is nearly always required (except following an Expanding Triangle) that the new trend move further and faster than any previous correction of the previous trend. For example, if the S&P is topping and the first decline off the high is retraced 80%, you know the conclusion of the advancing wave structure is not over. As long as a new high is not made, the last label of the advance (probably wave-5 or maybe wave-c) will be placed to the right of the highest high. When the psychology has run its course and the uptrend is over, a decline larger and faster than any corrective decline during the advance must occur to start the new downtrend.

پرسش و پاسخ با گلن نیلی-24

What are the behavior traits that differentiate :F3`s from :5`s?

ANSWER:

Before the release of Version 2.0 of Mastering Elliott Wave, Version 1.0 (called Elliott Waves in Motion) contained a far simpler version of Chapter 3 that was only 10 pages (the new Chapter 3 is 69 pages!). The older Chapter 3 stuck to the basics regarding the determination of whether a monowave is corrective or impulsive based on the behavior of waves that surrounded it. What many people don`t realize is Chapter 3 is a exercise in behavioral logic (i.e., the logical interaction of waves and how the behavior surrounding each monowave determines its internal, hidden nature). Once you understand the logic behind the process, the specific steps in Chapter 3 become unnecessary. Chapter 3 is not intended to be a constant requirement for proper wave analysis, but simply a crutch to help those early in their learning curve until the logical concepts of NEoWave become ingrained. Once ingrained, most of Chapter 3 can be ignored.

Before I can answer the above question, I must point out that :F3`s are a very specific type of correction that usually occur as the first leg of a more complex correction; consequently, I cannot compare the general behavior of :5`s with the specific, and typically lower degree behavior of :F3`s. On the other hand, I can address the differences between :3`s and :5`s of the same degree. In general, :3`s retrace no more (usually less) than 61.8% of a prior monowave (advancing or declining), will consume the same amount of time or more (usually more) as the prior monowave and will exhibit the same complexity (or greater) than the prior monowave.

On the other side of the coin, the behavior of :5`s is the opposite of :3`s; they will completely retrace the last monowave faster than it took to form, overall they will take less time than :3`s that follow their development and they will exhibit more violent behavior (i.e., they will cover more price in less time) than preceding and proceeding :3`s.